《Magriculture》A Note From The Author
Advertisement
Alright, so, some interesting feedback yesterday. I want you to know I do read these comments, and I do consider them.
There are some things, however, that I feel I need to clarify. When I said this is "at best a very rough draft" I wasn't kidding. A lot of this is me throwing stuff at the wall and seeing what sticks.
Someone said it felt like they MC was exploring the magic system at the same time as the Author. That's very true, this magic system isn't set in stone. In fact I've been considering if I need to change it. Should enchanting and Spells use the same runes? Should spells even use runes at all, should I instead move to 'patterns' in which mana has to flow? How the hell do I handle fire when everything so far has been in cubic feet? What about healing? These are all things I have to consider, and have been considering, I have some ideas, and now I need to see what works.
I very much so need to see an idea in action before I can say if it works or not, so some of this is me doing just that. The physical magics seem to work as they are, though I have to wonder, are they too powerful? Is he moving/making too much at once?
There was another comment about how it was like watching someone assemble an object from Ikea that didn't come with instructions and no one seemed to know how it should look. To be honest, that's kind of true. I don't have a set definite "this is how this will end". I have a general "this is where we're going" but getting there isn't yet set in stone.
Some things aren't going to work. Those parts will almost certainly have to be rewritten. Some things are going to look fine on the surface and then come back to bite me later, that will also mean some things will likely have to be rewritten. In the end, I expect that this entire story is going to have to be re-written to some degree or another. Will it look the same afterward, I'm not sure.
Advertisement
Now you're probably asking "why post this then?" and the answer to that is simple. I cannot develope in a vacuum, and my regular reader doesn't like VR stories. I need more than one perspective to help me see what works and what doesn't. I need people who say "This is a farming story in which he does precious little farming, you need to do more farming."
He has (as of the 23rd chapter) had 24 days of work (Might be 25, I think I missed a day). Should I be keeping such rigorous track of days? A lot has happened in that time, and not enough of it was farming. But I've felt like I needed to get him to a place where actual farming could happen. Perhaps I've taken too long to get there. That's another thing I need feedback on (See the 'do more farming' above).
There was some consternation that he stopped to build a house and barn. Should he have skipped those? Is him having animals a detriment to this story or a boon? Is him taking an hour to build a house a problem? Should he just go without one indefinitely? Where is he keeping his stuff? He's got a big inventory but it's slowly accumulating junk. If he had a normal inventory it'd be over full already. These are things I have to consider.
There's been a lot of discussion about the mana well(s), was that a poor choice? Could this story function without them if he had to purchase stones every few days to keep up? Should he use muscle power instead of magic power?
His farm hasn't been raided by jerks yet, is that realistic? Should he lose everything and be forced to start again? I tried writing that in several times, it didn't feel right, but that might be my own bias working against me. I want John to succeed and losing everything might just kill the story. Or maybe he'll somehow rise above it.
Advertisement
As I write this I realize I'm probably rambling a bit and losing the thread here so I'm going to stop after one last bit here.
This story is not a perfect, cohesive thing, which only needs minor edits and maybe some touch ups here and there. This is the messy, nitty gritty 'I'm writing the first draft and we're seeing where it takes us." That's not going to be for everyone. Hell that's probably not going to be for most people at all. But that's okay, if you're not enjoying it, if you're not in love with it, if you're finding yourself at odds with where it's going or how it's getting there, that's okay. But I need you to recognize this isn't a finished product, and it's not going to be for some time, if ever. I hope to write this to a conclusion. I hope to build a functional system that makes sense. I hope that farming happens and that John gets fat wads of cash. But we're on a journey folks, an adventure if you will. It's going to be rough, it's going to be tough, and there will absolutely be mistakes along the way.
If you're willing to accept all that, if you're ready to see growing pains and mistakes, triumphs and failures, things that work and things that don't. Then read on, and please, keep commenting. If you're not ready for that, that's okay too.
I'll post today's actual chapter later in the day. Fair warning, it's short. Fairer warning, the next three chapters (including this one) do not involve farming. In fact, two of them involve a dungeon crawl (which has to be the hardest thing I've written yet, it just doesn't feel right for the story).
And I realize I'm rambling agian, so I'm going to cut it off here. For those of you for whom this story isn't doing it. I'm sorry I didn't meet your expectations. For those of you who are going to continue reading anyway, thank you.
Advertisement
- In Serial222 Chapters
The Beauty Inside: Stealing The First Kiss, Get a Wife
A tragedy struck Wenceslas family 22 years ago. A noble family no one would fail to recognise throughout the country. They owned wealth which would not run out to be inherited through generations.
8 759 - In Serial10 Chapters
Path of the Thunderbird: Darkening Skies
A boy abandoned at an ancient school of warrior arts. A princess bartered away as a treaty bride. A lurking evil with the power to topple the world. Ji Yu Raijin is happy to live out his life serving his school, cultivating his life force, and learning the Path of Darkening Skies, an ancient and noble warrior art—until the day comes when he has to choose: remain true to the teachings of his path and allow his art to die out or commit an unforgivable sin and save the world. Second princess Shyong San Koida was born the only cripple in a dynasty of powerful warriors. With a broken life force, the only way Koida can contribute to her family’s empire is by sealing a strategic alliance to a barbarian leader with her hand in marriage. But hidden forces within the court conspire to stop the union and obliterate the Shyong San dynasty at all costs. At the intersection of the servant boy and the princess’s stories lies a secret, malignant art bent on destroying not only them, but the entire world. Darkening Skies is the first novel in the Path of the Thunderbird series, for fans of wuxia, xanxia, cultivation novels, demon beasts, and all styles of martial arts. Darkening Skies is written by eden Hudson, enthusiastic but terrible martial arts student and best-selling sci-fi and fantasy author of Rogue Dungeon and Jubal Van Zandt. Hey guys, eden/elfshanx here! I'm a huge fan of wuxia and xianxia, and a lifelong lover of martial arts and fantasy. This is my first attempt at putting them all together in one package. I hope it goes well! Thanks for reading!eden
8 158 - In Serial9 Chapters
The Hisix Chronicles
The misadventures of a brilliant gnome wizard and a murderous dark elf. A love story. With violence.
8 148 - In Serial7 Chapters
The Interconnectedness of Knowledge
please don't expect this to be a coherent story because this is only a form of mental dump for me to destress the mind and heart for my healthy well being. If your interested in reading my ideas as a form of reference to your work, please put a shout out to my page,
8 127 - In Serial30 Chapters
Road Trip - L.H
In which two people who hate each other go on a road trip with their friends.
8 66 - In Serial110 Chapters
Zodiac High-The Series
"When you have a school notoriously renowned for welcoming misconduct into its territory with open arms, a sophomore class with a knack for rule-breaking, and, of course, a complicated social system, what do you get, Ms. Cole?""Well, Miss, you get... chaos."..... Varsity High isn't an ordinary school. Attended by the rich, the clever, the courageous and the mischievous alike, there is never a dull moment... or, as a matter of fact, one that isn't out-of-control in every single way. Welcome to your worst nightmare... or, perhaps, your best daydream...
8 111

