*The scene opens up to Athanasia, Gray, Happy, and Natsu walking through the forest in silence*

"out of all the mission that Natsu could have chosen why does it have to be protecting a princess" though Athanasia

"aww come on Athanasia it wont be so bad" said Lucy in the back of her mind

"great the ghost is trying to cheer me up" said Athanasia

"hey what was that suppose to mean" said Lucy offend

"i meant what I said" yelled Athanasia in the back of her mind

"hmmm your mean" said Lucy as she crossed her arm

*Athanasia sweatdropped*

"has she always been like this" though Athanasia

"hey Athy?" said Natsu

"huh? oh yes Natsu" said Athanasia

"is something the matter you haven't said a word since we left the guild" said Nastu

"aye this is the quickest i ever seen you be" said Happy

"guys Im fine I'm just excited that I'm going on my first mission that is all" said Athanasia as she walks faster ahead of the group

*Nastu and happy looked at each other and run after Athanasia*

"actually its not the mission that I'm think about" though Athanasia

"Why cant you love me too father I'm your real daughter not that fake" said Athanasia

"such words i don't think about i never seen you as my child" said Claude coldly

end of flashback .......................................................................

"hey lily if i were to ever return to oblian again i hope it for me to bring you back here to flore i have a feeling that you would love it here and including the guild that i join who i now call my family i just hope i would never be hurt like that ever again" though Athanasia who was looking at the sky

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

*in obelian deep within the chambers a woman with brown hair and blue eyes was seen chained up to a wall will injuries all over her body*

"you know this could all be avoid if you just tell me where my daughter is" said Claude

"even if i knew where the princess was i would never tell you where she was" said Lilian

"should i punish her again your majesty" said a knight

"no she will talk if lilian knows what good for her" said Claude

"what's good for me? all you ever do is hurt the princess why all of a suddenly you you want her back she's not important to you" said Lilian

*claude looked really angrily*

"athanasia is my daughter I'm worried about her" said Claude

"worried about her? you call pushing her aside for that grateful brat who is not even your real child and now your worried about her? I'm sorry your majesty but that is hard to believe" said Lilian

"punish her now but don't kill her" said Claude

"yes you majesty" said a knight

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

*Athanasia stops for a minute and a tear slides down from her face*

"what is this feeling? what do i feel like something bad is happening to lily? maybe this mission is making me over think many things" though Athanasia

"Athy come on!" yelled Gray

"just a sec I'm coming" said Athanasia as she runs to catch up with the group

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

*Lilian is shown very injured with blood leaving everywhere from her body*

"knight take here to the doctor once she is better bring her back" said Claude

"yes your majoresty" said the knight as he picks up Lilian and take her to the doctor

"Princess i will always protect you like your my own daughter" though Lilian as she passes out