《Write Better: Tips and tricks》Said vs Whispered, spoke, lied, etc.
Advertisement
There's a big problem about adverbs in tags that we'll cover later. Presently, we're going to focus on verb choice. Particularly, said vs any other alternate word you can replace it with.
Said, spoke, drawled, whispered, lied, agreed, acknowledged, cheered, chortled, laughed, exclaimed, shouted, yelled, retorted, mumbled, quipped, asked, bragged, accused, called, advised, demanded, insisted, etc.
There are literally hundreds of replacements for this word!
And hundreds of writers have written articles and blogs and sections about sticking to said.
Almost all of the writers of these articles will indeed tell you that's okay to insert something different here and there. And if they don't, it's not uncommon for folks to pry into the author's writing and hoist up an example where the person broke their own rule. "What a hypocrite!" they say. "It's bad for us to use different words to replace said, but in their first chapter they subbed in a new word six times!"
I'll say it now and I'll say it in future chapters:
That being said, it doesn't mean your sentence is the right one. There's a reason most people will tell you to stay with said over its dozens of variants.
I'll do my best to provide the logic behind this.
It's difficult to explain. The word is on the page. They read it, but they don't read it. It's like your bedroom ceiling. Nine times out of ten, you know the ceiling is there and you see the ceiling but you don't really see it (unless you're bored out of your mind or there's a giant spider looming overhead).
Variations of "said" can be the spider. It's not necessarily a bad thing, but your eye is drawn to it more than usual. Usually, the bigger the spider, the more you pay attention. For our purposes, the more unusual the replacement (usually this means more syllables), the more the reader stops to think about it.
Advertisement
Most of the time, if you throw in a variation people tend to lose track of it anyway, unless it's one of eye-catching giants.
Bob said, "Let's go to the beach."
"I hate the ocean," Chris replied. "And in case you haven't noticed, I don't need Clara to see my bulging gut."
"What does it matter?" Tom said. "She'll like you for who you are or she won't."
"But I like her."
"So do I," Bob said, "and I've been working out."
"Great," Chris repined.
Because it's so noticeable in these cases, the poor writer is often scolded for a different (correctly used or not) word, when really they just need to change up their method of tagging.
They used such little variety, that when they do change things up, it doesn't feel right! And then they feed into the "don't use anything but said" rants.
For me, this is the number one reason new writers are discouraged from using words beside said (and attaching adverbs).
We don't want you not to use it. We want you to learn how to write dialogue so convincing/strong, it conveys tone without you having to say it!
Honestly, you can't tag every sentence, so you've got to learn how to address things like mood and tone. A good way to practice that is to remove the tags and let the dialogue do the talking.
In this case, you commonly get something like "verb adverb" (he said lovingly). The writer fails to write strong dialogue and scenes, so they are stuck with a tag that conveys the meaning for them.
Sometimes writers get the dialogue and scene perfect. It says everything it needs to, and then they attach a tag that says the Exact. Same. Thing. In an effort not to have too much repetition, the tag is often the first (and easiest) thing an editor asks to be changed or eliminated.
Advertisement
Again, in this case it isn't wrong, it's just not always necessary.
"Where are we?" he asked.
"I didn't kill Myrtle," Juliet denied.
"Shh! They'll hear us!" Kayla whispered.
When you consider how many people are writing and how many beginners there are (especially in the age of the internet) it's easy to understand where these people are coming from when they tell you to keep it simple. Doesn't mean they're right all the time, but if you can effectively use tags you'll quickly become an exception to the rule. :)
Advertisement
- In Serial79 Chapters
The Devil's Foundry
How I learned to stop worrying and solve my problems with demons until demons stopped solving my problems. - A snarky villain and her heroic nemesis blow themselves up and land on a fantasy world. They find themselves faced with two prospects: learn to cooperate and respect someone they've fought against for years, or be swept away by the powers that be. Because Pride always comes before the fall.
8 329 - In Serial63 Chapters
Yora Chronicles
[Arc 0 - The Prologue] Airen and Yuelei Casteya - Two twins separated in act of revenge not of their own doing. One is sent to the frozen north, where she is adopted by a frost phoenix and taught to survive in the harshest of conditions, eventually meeting with the forces that govern nature itself. The other is sent to the southern deserts and is saved by a band of slaves-turned-raiders who take him in as one of their own, where he eventually came into contact with a being that calls herself the History Eater. The two sought power and the forces of the world would soon listen, but not without their own aspirations. And perhaps if the two were to meet again, they would be so warped by their own hands and would not even recognize the other. [Arc 1 - Disciple of the History Eater & Knighthood] Under the guidance of Fieluri, the whimsical being from the Archive, Airen moves south to the Red Slate Republic to attend Stonewall Military Academy. There, he finds himself wrapped up in the History Eater's ploys, and at the same time, learns of the somber side of society in the slave-driven republic. Eventually, under Fieluri's instruction, he descends into the depths of dungeons where he eventually reunites with an old acquaintance. Yuelei, who has grown used to living in the snowy mountains, moves north to the Holy Land of Ecclisa to attend the Royal Knight Academy. After Lin leaves, she slowly adapts to living with humans again, but not without ceaseless caution. The thinly-veiled peace is eventually broken, for the monsters that haunted the nights in the Whitefrost Mountains are returning once more. In response, the Holy Land of Ecclisa slowly prepare for war, but Yuelei is not just a mere bystander. All paths eventually leads to conflict. When it arrives, one can choose to deter it away, or to revel in it. [Arc 2 - WIP] NOTE- Based on an internal discussion, please be advised the earlier chapters of this novel [Arc 0 and Arc I] is going through a major revision and rewrite to gap the 6 years experience since the first draft of this novel. For questions,concerns,comments or contributions, feel free to join us on our discord: https://discord.gg/Vdp2k6v © 2018 by Phyantasm. All Rights Reserved.
8 444 - In Serial11 Chapters
Pimps in Jiang Hu!
Travis didn't land on the right side of the law most of the time, but his life was cut short unjustly. So, when he woke up in the body of Wang Tao, a cultivator from Jiang Hu, you could imagine his shock! Follow the hilarious, blood-boiling, heart-wrenching journey of Travis - I mean - Wang Tao, as he searches for the perfect butt and faces the challenges of the brutal dog-eat-dog world depicted in most Xianxia novels.
8 184 - In Serial149 Chapters
Everything will be my way!
A young man with an extraordinary mind is off on an exciting adventure when he mysteriously wakes up in the body of a feeble slave-guy in a different, rich in quirks world. The main character, a selfish jerk, would use extreme means to achieve his goals. However, he never allows his base instincts to overrule his sense of decency. He always pays back both good and bad deeds. Will his (terrible/excellent) mentality help him make a fresh start? Will he get through misfortunes and hardships of the new world?
8 146 - In Serial13 Chapters
The Happenstance of Samuel Hayden
This is the story of Samuel as he stumbles through the game of life with a losing hand in a world where literal forces of nature roam the land and heroes of legends have a list of feats as great as their bar tab. Follow Samuel in a world where nothing can be underestimated, including him.
8 188 - In Serial13 Chapters
Seeking Clarity
A boy wakes up in a hospital. He can't remember anything at all. Memories slowly come back as he wanders the building, and he attempts to piece together why he is there....At least, that's how it starts.
8 127

