《Salty Book Review》Review #6
Advertisement
Sorry for the terrible cropping. As you can see, I'm on the phone with my boyfriend. He practically dragged me out of bed, motivating me to continue with my reviews. Anywho, you asked for a brutally honest review so here goes...
Your title is very mysterious. For some reason, when I read it, I imagine myself on the beach with your book in hand. I love it! My only issue is that I don't see how it correlates to the plot of the story. That's what a title is supposed to do after all.
5/10
Your genre choice was a perfect fit and I find no fault in this whatsoever.
10/10
Your description was poorly written to the point where I questioned if it was written by someone in middle school. You mixed a lot of beginner words and sentences with advanced words that don't fit right with the genre. This is a YA book so it's best to upgrade your vocabulary to reel the reader in.
E.g: Instead of writing, "Nichole Woods is a cynic, and doesn't believe herself to be a good person."
I'd change that to, "Nichole Woods' paranoia towards others has caused her to question her own morality."
Instead of, "After a traumatic event Nichole is kicked out of her public school and placed in a prestigious private school by her wealthy father."
I'd change that to, "After a traumatic event at her public school, Nichole was transferred to a more prestigious private school with the help of her wealthy father."
"She has ill feelings towards her past and Nichole struggles with it." Change that to, "She holds resentment towards her past trauma and she struggles to cope."
3/10
There's plenty to choose from but not much information is given for me to conduct an opinion. I'll be reading on but for now, I'll just review Nichole.
Advertisement
(Nichole) I see a lot of my past self in her. She's quiet unless spoken to and she pushes her pain away to deal with the burdens of family drama. At first, I was gonna say how annoying she is but after rereading the blurb, I was able to sympathize with her.
10/10
I haven't read far enough to see anything so I'll leave this blank.
N/A
I want to see more of her life outside of school. What does she like to do(besides vandalizing her journals) and how does she deal with her mother's alcoholism? How did her father acquire his wealth?
5/10
This book has been on my mind for a long time now. Mainly Nichole. I'm gonna keep this in my library for future reading.
10/10
You chose three so this section will most likely be longer than the others.
(Characters) All of the characters seem too nice and for no reason. I've never been to a school where there aren't at least five stuck-up girls or three womanizing boys.
(Plot) Already completed.
(Writing Style) Your writing style is poor. I've noticed a lot of writers tend to tell instead of show and that can push some readers away.
E.g. "I go to my room." That's considered telling.
"The clicking of my shoes radiates around me as I walk to my room." That's showing. Also, your punctuation is poor throughout the story. May I suggest you trying out Grammarly? I'm gonna place screenshots that I captured while reading. These are to show you exactly what I saw as an issue.
That doesn't flow correctly in my opinion. I'd change it to, "As I lean against the kitchen island, the cold tiles send chills running up my spine despite my flesh being covered with stockings."
Advertisement
This portion was choppy but I'll show you examples of how I'd rewrite it in the same format as how you wrote it.
"Her hand is cold to the touch."
"'Come on," I murmur as I lay her arm over my shoulder, tugging her to her feet. 'Let's get you to bed.'"
"As I guide her to her bedroom, she rests her head against my shoulder and she gives my arm a gentle squeeze."
"'You're so sweet,' she coos from adoration, her words stretching out longer than necessary."
Thank you for sending me your book! I look forward to reading another one of your works and recommend me to your friends if you're pleased with this review.
Advertisement
- In Serial88 Chapters
War of Seasons
Dorothea Atlin is the young, apathetic leader of the neutral territory of Sirpo, a chilly land hovering above the continuously warring factions of Sacer and Ghuria, whose devastating magics have ravaged their people and lands time and time again. Following a shocking attack and a cruel deception, Dorothea grows her conscience and takes up arms, using her self-destructive ability to manipulate the flow of time to ensure Sacer’s victory. Her growing understanding of war and the two factions is guided by Iree Nobelis, the determined and enthralling commander of Sacer’s forces, Ariana Kingfisher, a steely swordswoman of mixed Ghurian and Sacerian descent, and Rhys Tamlin, a kind but haunted soldier who goes to challenge Dorothea’s self-imposed celibacy and join her on a mutual journey of healing from the tragic legacies of the Atlin family and wars between the nations. Meanwhile, Dorothea’s only friend and deserter from the Sacerian military, Shark Olyen, returns to their homeland to face the family that disowned them and finds more than they bargained for in meeting Cerid Creed, a noble whose duty to his people clashes with his desires in romance and in life, much like Shark’s did long before. As their developing or preexisting loves and differing convictions on how to achieve peace create rifts between these major players, Dorothea experiences a personal revolution that leads her to fight for what she believes is right, no matter the cost. A slow-burn story that takes time setting up the psychology and motivations of characters for explosive payoff later down the line. Cover by Ben Arisson, who is also a wonderful author on this website!
8 197 - In Serial16 Chapters
The Good Nurse ✔️
Jack Grealish finds himself in hospital.Becky is his nurse, she hasn't got a clue about football and had never heard of Jack Grealish before he turned up on her ward.They have a connection, but it wouldn't be right........Can they make it work? Their worlds are wildly different. Do opposites really attract?Very slow burn to start with....
8 190 - In Serial6 Chapters
Remembering You
21-year-old Yoo Hyun-ki and Lee Chanwoo are two boys who have been best friends since Junior High. A terrible accident sends Chanwoo into a coma, leaving Hyun-Ki to diligently wait for his return to consciousness. The thing is, Chanwoo was never just his best friend. To Hyun-ki, he was always so much more than that. However, when new feelings seem to suddenly arise after the accident, things start to stir and blur the line between best friends and something more. This leaves both boys with a lot of figuring out to do and an unexpected journey to embark on- that is, if these new and unexplored territories can be welcomed on both parts. ~ a love story told from both points of view. FOLLOW ME ON WATTPAD TO READ FULL STORY: https://wattpad.com/user/sharkymaru *started 5/1/20* --> if posted anywhere else other than here and Webnovel @petalpower or on my Wattpad @sharkymaru, it's being stolen! >;c
8 85 - In Serial9 Chapters
Erind x Deen Alternate Reality Spin-Off of REND
Main Story: REND Due to popular demand of readers of REND, I'm writing a non-canon spin-off to pair Erind Hartwell, the main character, and Amber Deen Leska, (probably) the most popular side character of the story. I separated this from the main story because a romantic type of relationship between these two is not possible there. It'll be mostly light-hearted, slow progression of Erind and Deen's relationship, will mostly be fluffy interaction with maybe some adult scenes here and there.
8 215 - In Serial52 Chapters
Challenge accepted(Completed)
Amanda who is super rich kid and most famous girl in her who doesn't care anyone's feeling. On other side Maaya is scholarship student who is always shy and doesn't talk to people much and very conservative. How life changes when these two girls stay together and how there life takes turns and they end up together.⇥TachlCm3⇤1st ranking in lifetime (14th Nov 2018)
8 195 - In Serial5 Chapters
Tintagel **Open Novella Contest Entry**
Open Novella Contest EntryFantastical Fiction #2 The Dark Lord#OpenNovellaContest2019
8 162

