《Book reviews *Requests Closed*》'Fragile Strength (Kakashi x oc)' by MinaKashi_hokage
Advertisement
'Fragile Strength' is a fanfic centered around Kakashi (from Naruto) and the author's OC Kasuno. It is, of course, a love story.
The plot is kind of all over the place. There's Kasuno and her budding romance with Kakashi, hindered by a disease/curse threatening her life, and the plot essentially consists of the drama this all comes with (perhaps mixed with certain plot points from the Naruto series, but I wouldn't know; I've never seen Naruto).
You see, this is where it gets tricky. 'Popular show character x OC' stories are held to high standards. It needs a strong plot and an OC able to blend seamlessly into the universe you're inserting them in. On top of that, their interactions with the show's characters shouldn't feel out of place, and naturally, the story's prose must be written well in general too.
This is were problems start to arise. The plot was decent, the disease/curse was interesting... but it wasn't particularly strong. It didn't stand out. Why? Because our MC Kasuno couldn't carry it. I couldn't figure out just _what_ she added to the story, the plot, the Naruto universe. She didn't blend in. She felt inserted. Her character didn't stand out. If you asked me to describe her personality right now, I wouldn't be able to. I've seen countless OCs over the years, and Kasuno isn't any different; she only seems to be there for the sake of her romance with Kakashi.
Tricky thing number two. When writing Popular Character x OC, make _absolutely_ sure they have chemistry. Average Reader loves Popular Character. Average Reader does _not_ want to see Popular Character They Love end up with someone they don't feel is 'good enough'. Like I said, OCs are held to a rather high standard, but we've covered that. Point is: You need some crazy chemistry. Kasuno and Kakashi don't have that right now. Yes, there are some cute moments and sweet oneliners, but it's simply not enough to carry the story.
Advertisement
How could we create more chemistry? Well, a good start would be giving Kakashi more screen time. For a main character, he gets very little time to shine. Take more time to show us (and I say _show_, not tell) how his feelings for Kasuno develop and what he's up to in general. You admit in an author's note that the story has a lack of Kakashi, author, and you say that's because you're bad at writing his character. Then why are you writing a story centered around him in the first place? My advice would be to really delve deep into his character and study it to write it more accurately; it can only benefit your story and characterization, promise.
Seeing as I've never seen Naruto, I can't say much about how 'in character' everyone was, but based on what I do know, most was decently accurate. Some characters were a little over-the-top and the humour could be cheesy at times, but I think I'll classify that as staying true to the show; it seems the kind of humour I'd expect from a fic based on a Shounen Anime.
Last but not least… The GPS. Grammar, spelling, punctuation.
You have some work to do, my friend!
There's tense-switching galore. The state of the grammar just kind of saddens me. Misspellings were frequent (my favourite was 'dispissed' instead of 'dismissed'). Punctuation could definitely be more professional. Practice, my dude. Practice. Edit and practice. Learn through trial and error by all means. But from an editorial perspective, this story is a hard-to-follow mess. So before fixing anything that has to do with the plot or characters... Go do some major editing.
This has potential, it does. But there are technical problems in dire need of fixing, and it needs to work on making itself truly stand out.
Rating: 4
Advertisement
- In Serial40 Chapters
Griffon's Fury!
During one usual evening, a boy was born. As if feeling it, ancient griffon opened his eyes from slumber. The skies trembled under the visions of the fire and blood. A beat appeared inside an egg. It was the prince who will restore the Empire. The fate drums have rung. The war and change were coming! Participant of Royal Road writathon What to expect from the novel: -Genius and careful MC -Detailed worldbuilding, serving to introduce the reader to the fantasy world -Some elements from the eastern cultivation genre -A steadfast focus on MC's story and his actions in his attempts to get stronger and unlock his memory.
8 153 - In Serial16 Chapters
The Story of an Unusual Dungeon
Access Program: SynopsisInitializing Synopsis............Initializing complete: This story centers around a new dungeon near a city, the dungeon core creates monsters and traps in an attempt to defend it'self from the evil intruders that seek to destroy the innocent and vulnerable Core but after creating the monsters all the intruders are scared of them, I did a great job didn't I? These monsters are my pride! Hmm? Why does my status still say: [Possible Threat: Very High]?Synopsis: SaveSaving Synopsis.........Saving complete (Cover page is just a placeholder until I can get some way to draw a good digitalize drawing of my own. Need a drawing tablet and good comp for that)
8 84 - In Serial13 Chapters
The Golem Mancer
Roy Treves is a...Happy....Troubled youth who after a 'unfortunate accident' was able to reincarnate as a Demon. He is given the Blessing of [Methodical Randomness] meaning he is given a Random Ability and everything in his life will follow suit with it! Too bad this Blessing of his is a little weird. Used as pawn in the game of gods, follow Roy as he makes his own army of life long 'friends'. He who has no one, makes his own. *Contains Small amount of Cursing and What you'd expect after being attacked by a wolf with sharp iron teeth... so PG-16 (No 'mature' things) -Romance is very late in the fiction as he starts as a baby. How can you start a relationship as a baby? Don't answer. You just can't -----Hey everyone. INFO here (I-f N-ot F-or O-ne) I always wanted to post my own fiction, especially one with summoning Golems! Just as a warning for everyone I basically failed English (70% is a fail for me) I do not type most of this on my Phone anymore! Most of the typing and editing done on my laptop. Other than that enjoy!-----Updates every Week or less . After every Five Chapter I will take a break to plan what i am going to do next. Chapter are Usually 3,500+ words (Right now 4,000+)~INFO
8 173 - In Serial13 Chapters
Dungeon Misfits
(Warning: The story is still currently in a poor quality state, read on at your own risk.) After the devastating great war, many people were left with poverty, hardship and starvation. Due to this, miscreants and mendicants were a common occurrence here. Thus at such hard times, many different kinds of desperate people would try to delve and discover various dangerous dungeons. And it was at such times, where different people and monsters converge, that various interesting stories and situations could happen. It could be about an aspiring necromancer seeking to find a place in the dungeon in order to seclude himself to his studies and research on necromancy. It could be a story of a struggling group of bandits, deserters and highwaymen using a dungeon cave as a hideout. Even about a bunch of struggling newbies adventurers stumbling in a dungeon. Or perhaps about a certain diabolist, a witch, and a rogue who are ostracised by others due to their professions, being forced to work together as a team in a dungeon. All the while, encountering even more eccentric people on the way. Different people, different situations, but whatever happens inside the dungeon remains to be seen.
8 83 - In Serial12 Chapters
Wishing You A Lousy B-Day
Being abandoned at birth and suffered a life of hardship, the MC has long since developed a twisted and ruthless personality. Upon meeting his birth father by accident, MC decides to take revenge by seducing his father’s partner, a mysterious and affluent young man. Turns out, things are not what they seemed, and bleeding hearts all shattered. A fun exercise in dog blood and heart poison.It hurt so bad, but it feels so good!Let's all suffer together lalala~
8 63 - In Serial65 Chapters
HASEENAH
A very touch hearted story which consist of a poor girl with her mom, that under go so many hatred from her step mom, description can't explain, but let's ruin together
8 179

