《How to Write Stories People Will Love》Question 21: Narrating dialogue
Advertisement
asks: Can you write about narrating dialogue? Things like, "he said" or "she nodded" or just describing actions.
Narrating dialogue can be tricky because it's easy to become repetitive or annoying. There's nothing wrong with "he said" and "she said", but when that's all there is, the repetition stands out. And not in a good way.
When narrating dialogue, your goal should be to make it feel like natural, uninterrupted flow. Anything that confuses, annoys, or slows down a reader should be minimized if possible. Like these:
Don't get me wrong. I'm a big fan of complex vocabulary, and I love learning new words. But the word needs to fit the occasion. If you're going to talk about "pulchritudinous splendor", make sure the character using this phrase would actually say such a thing when describing something.
"He asked" is a dialogue tag. So is "she said", "Sally quipped", and "the man roared." Every line in the dialogue does not need to have one. Their purpose is to eliminate confusion. Use them anytime it's unclear who's speaking, but don't underestimate the intelligence of your reader. When only two people are talking, you can get away with no tags at all for expanses of dialogue. This makes for a snappier conversation. Just pop one in every now and then to remind the reader who's turn it is to speak. Like this:
"What do you mean I'm off the team?" Jane asked the captain.
"The team had a vote."
"About me?"
"Yes."
"What did I do?"
"It's more about what you didn't do."
Jane sighed. "And what did I not do?"
"Play like you're on a team."
Many of the dialogue tags can be replaced with actions. This does double duty of preventing excessive tags, as well as giving the reader a better idea of what the scene looks like in their imaginations. Example:
Advertisement
Danny stomped ahead, steam practically puffing out of his hears as he dragged his little brother along by the hand.
Jane ran up to him. "Danny, wait! Don't be mad."
He whirled around. "Why shouldn't I be mad? You just insulted my brother."
"I didn't mean to."
"She didn't mean to," Elton echoed before sticking a thumb into his mouth.
Danny ignored him. "But you shouldn't have said those things."
"I know."
"Then why did you?"
Elton tugged on his brother's hand. "Hungry."
Jane looked at the little boy. "I'm sorry, Elton."
His little face lit up. "French fries?"
---
In this way, it feels like an actual scene rather than some heads talking.
Advertisement
- In Serial128 Chapters
Heart Over Sword
Evanna’s world came crashing down the moment the physician gave her mother 6 months left to live. But after discovering a long, lost secret hidden by the elves, the sheltered and naïve princess sets off on a quest to find the one item that could change the hands of fate. In order to do this, she must come face to face with the Flori, the heartless and deadliest of the elven kingdoms.
8 1234 - In Serial23 Chapters
What Was Lost Outside Time
What happens to a mind, subjected to an infinite span of time? What remains, when it is taken out again? This is the story of an individual reborn after such time has passed that nothing remains of what it was; an individual who must learn once again what it is to be, beginning with awareness of the idea of awareness, and growing from there; from awareness of self, to awareness of others, to awareness of society, and on. This is the story of a mind; growing, learning, adapting, and becoming more. -- Currently the first three chapters are - well, kind of experimental. I both like and hate these; they were a pain to write, and I'm told by at least one person that they're painful to get through, but I think something like them is necessary to set one of the basic ideas about the way the story is written. It gets slightly more normal after that, the first arc of the story is rather "battle school", and I think I may need to go back and edit it - the characterization didn't end up working out as well as I had originally hoped, unfortunately, and ended up rather weak to my eye. I may go back and add a sub-plot or two, depending on how well I can handle the intended perspective shift of the second arc. -- Currently on hiatus, in case that wasn't obvious. I'm debating between rewriting large portions of what I've already written, and just finishing out the story, but either way, I don't actually have a clear idea of what I want to do right now. If I'm still feeling the same way in a few months I'll put a chapter up explaining where the story was going, maybe, so the people who have enjoyed it can know where the story was intended to go, and close this out.
8 204 - In Serial18 Chapters
Different World with Save and Load: A Horror Story
Being strong and being weak is a form of perspective. Are you really as weak as you think you are? Do you really have the power to level mountains and rend the seas? If people tell you are god then you are god, if people tell you are nothing then you are nothing. But who actually sees the whole picture? A not-so-good man (evil) managed to get transported to a not-so-real world (game-like) by a not-so-caring god (lazy). The world uses the all-so-famous “stats”, but he has no access to the so-called “system”. At least he managed to get a cheat from the lazy god, even if it took all his potential. What will a greedy villain with the ability to reset his progress do in a world that is more fake then real with a godlike hero, and a non-caring god?
8 89 - In Serial7 Chapters
The Weaver's Blade
Zizal Gand is a man in search of redemption. The ex-thief, who's only hopes lay in service to the Weaver, must rely on the skills that had taken so much and on those whom hold sway over his future. As war approaches, Zizal must become more than a thief, he must become the Weaver's blade.
8 74 - In Serial18 Chapters
Aria of Memory
Try as one might, the will of the Crystals shall not be denied. As ashes turn to ashes and dust turns to dust, so too does the radiant brilliance dim to deepest darkness. The Fallen One--a young woman of unknown origin, afflicted with amnesia, has come to the Star where the Crystals once held sway. Imbued with power beyond her ken and chosen to bear a burdensome mantle, she fights for friends, she lives for love, she dies for duty, and like a phoenix rises anew to continue her journey. Her quest is without end--her vigil, everlasting; yet, she does not stand alone against the vicissitudes of the Forces of Ruin. Alone or not, however, she shall become what she must. Cross-posted from AO3
8 178 - In Serial50 Chapters
Keeping It Halal
I turned around. Then I saw him. Same curly hair. Same bright beautiful brown eyes. Same charming features. He looked the same but even more manly. And Mashallah- He looked more handsome than ever! I couldn't believe it. After all this time I've found him.Mariam is 15 turning 16 and she thinks that moving to Canada was the worst decision! Until she meets Kareem, her ultimate crush. One thing to remember though: she has to keep it HALAL. Please note that this book is NOT just for Muslims it's just a Muslim Love Story. It is welcome for anybody to read. So please, enjoy!
8 126

